Fifteen years after the adoption of Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers to member States on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity, the report provides a thorough overview of the state of implementation of CM/Rec(2010)5.
The picture is mixed, denoting increased polarisation.
More member States have enabled legal gender recognition based on self-determination and same-sex partnerships are legally recognised in an increased number of States, either through marriage equality or the adoption of registered partnership regimes.
Furthermore, some member States have advanced protections for intersex persons, introduced penalties to punish conversion practices and tailored anti-discrimination protections through an intersectional lens.
Progress has however not been even. Legal gender recognition has been rendered impossible in some member States, through constitutional court rulings or the enactment of legislation, despite the European Court of Human Rights having ruled on member States’ obligations in this respect.
Despite the positive trend of a rising number of LGBTI Pride marches, including outside capital cities, in other places freedom of assembly and association has been curtailed. LGBTI civil society spaces are shrinking and LGBTI human rights defenders face increasing backlash. Opposition to organising LGBTI events has led to both legislative bans and de facto bans in some State.
In this context, the Report showcases best practices from member States across all 12 thematic chapters concerned, provides policy recommendations both horizontally and thematically, and will be used as a basis for future Council of Europe work to continue advancing LGBTI human rights in Europe.
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
BACKGROUND AND METHODOLOGY
IMPLEMENTATION, REVIEW AND REMEDIES
THEMATIC CHAPTER I ‑ RIGHT TO LIFE, SECURITY & PROTECTION
Part 1 – Hate Crime
Part 2 – Hate Speech
THEMATIC CHAPTER II ‑ FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATION
THEMATIC CHAPTER III ‑ FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION AND PEACEFUL ASSEMBLY
THEMATIC CHAPTER IV ‑ RIGHT TO RESPECT FOR PRIVATE AND FAMILY LIFE
THEMATIC CHAPTER V ‑ EMPLOYMENT
THEMATIC CHAPTER VI ‑ EDUCATION
THEMATIC CHAPTER VII ‑ HEALTH
THEMATIC CHAPTER VIII ‑ HOUSING
THEMATIC CHAPTER IX ‑ SPORTS
THEMATIC CHAPTER X ‑ ASYLUM 73
THEMATIC CHAPTER XI ‑ NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS INSTITUTIONS
THEMATIC CHAPTER XII ‑ DISCRIMINATION ON MULTIPLE GROUNDS
RECOMMENDATIONS